Differences Between Mac Lockdown And Port Security - HP ProCurve 2910al Access Security Manual

Configuring and Monitoring Port Security
MAC Lockdown
13-24
Other Useful Information. Once you lock down a MAC address/VLAN pair
on one port that pair cannot be locked down on a different port.
You cannot perform MAC Lockdown and 802.1X authentication on the same
port or on the same MAC address. MAC Lockdown and 802.1X authentication
are mutually exclusive.
Lockdown is permitted on static trunks (manually configured link aggrega­
tions).

Differences Between MAC Lockdown and Port Security

Because port-security relies upon MAC addresses, it is often confused with
the MAC Lockdown feature. However, MAC Lockdown is a completely differ­
ent feature and is implemented on a different architecture level.
Port security maintains a list of allowed MAC addresses on a per-port basis.
An address can exist on multiple ports of a switch. Port security deals with
MAC addresses only while MAC Lockdown specifies both a MAC address and
a VLAN for lockdown.
MAC Lockdown, on the other hand, is not a "list." It is a global parameter on
the switch that takes precedence over any other security mechanism. The
MAC Address will only be allowed to communicate using one specific port on
the switch.
MAC Lockdown is a good replacement for port security to create tighter
control over MAC addresses and which ports they are allowed to use (only
one port per MAC Address on the same switch in the case of MAC Lockdown).
(You can still use the port for other MAC addresses, but you cannot use the
locked down MAC address on other ports.)
Using only port security the MAC Address could still be used on another port
on the same switch. MAC Lockdown, on the other hand, is a clear one-to-one
relationship between the MAC Address and the port. Once a MAC address has
been locked down to a port it cannot be used on another port on the same
switch.
The switch does not allow MAC Lockdown and port security on the same port.