A.2.3. Risk assessment conclusion
Values of the risk components for the unprotected structure are reported in the regulation.
The public service loss (L2) and the economic loss (L4) are relevant for this type of structure. It is
required to evaluate the need for protection. This implies the determination of the risk
risk
for L4 with the risk components
4
tolerable risk
below the tolerable risk.
According to the IEC 62305-2, calculation of the risk parameters is shown as follows:
Table A.4: Risk components for different types of damage and source of damage (IEC 62305-2)
Damage
S1
D2
=
D3
=
Calculation of the risk components requirement is as shown in Table A.5.
Table A.5: Weather radar at CWRP: Environment and structure characteristics
Input parameter
Ground flash density [ 1/km
Number of over voltages [1/year]
Structure dimensions [m]
Location factor of structure
Use the Table A.4 and the Table A.5, risk assessment result will be calculated. The result is shown
in the Table A.6. Therefore considering current condition, the weather radar is not protected by
existing lightning rods. Total risk value is exceeded of the tolerable risk value.
We'll propose solution for this later, protecting the radar by additional lightning rod and adapt LPL
Class IV. Assessment for this solution is also shown in the Table A.6. According to the result is
almost half of the tolerable risk value, so the condition of the radar turned into safe.
Type of damage
D2: Physical Damage
D3 failure of
internal systems
Total
Tolerable
−3
. Suitable protection measures will be selected to reduce the risk to or
= 10
S2
×
×
×
×
=
×
2
/year ]
Table A.6: Risk assessment result at CWRP
Symbol
= 0.001
,
,
,
,
Source of damage
S3
= (
+
= (
+
×
Symbol
L, W, H
Current Condition
0
0
0.01
0.1323
-6
3.36 x 10
-4
3.36 x 10
0.134
NG
56
and
and to compare it with the
) ×
×
) ×
×
=
Value
16.8
-3
2.709 x 10
0
13.227
-4
3.36 x 10
-2
3.36 x 10
0.95, 0.95, 3.177
0.5
Protected by LPL IV
0
0
0.0005
-6
1.37 x 10
-7
1.68 x 10
-5
1.68 x 10
0.00052
Safety
for L2 and
2
S4
×
×